Now, I have made it known across several platforms and in many conversations that I do not condone musical adaptations of other media. Yes, of course, some adaptations are wonderful (I’m talkin’ Legally Blonde, Newsies, Hamilton, etc.) but, to me at lease, they just show a lack of creativity, that people cannot come up with their own stories. Or maybe it’s worse. Maybe it’s just that audiences only want what they already know, a gimmick.
While adaptations are currently running Broadway with no end in sight, more and more announcements of more and more adaptations are happening everyday. Today is no different. Today Hasbro, yes the board game company, announced their intention of adapting Clue for the stage. Technically speaking, this is going to be an adaptation of an adaption as they are using the 1985 movie as its basis.
However, this might lead to an interesting stage show. The film had 3 alternate endings which could lend itself to a sort of create-your-own-adventure stage show, think The Mystery of Edwin Drood. If you remember, The Mystery of Edwin Drood had several alternate musical numbers and the audience would vote for their favorite characters. I believe a style such as this would work well for this type of show.
This all being said, back in June of this year Hasbro announced different plans for a musical adaptation of their other quite popular board game, Monopoly. This one is a bit different, as there is not a film serving as its base. Still, this one might not be terrible, and I actually have high hopes for it.
I’m reminded of a recent Show People interview that Paul Wontorek did with Nick Blaemire. In that interview, Blaemire spoke about his involvement in the Spongebob Squarepants musical, saying that it could so easily just be an episode up on the boards and yet it deals with intense topics like climate change, violence, and racism.
This is something that might work best with Monopoly. That game is the quintessential example of American greed. That game is about owning land, raising prices, and sending your friends to jail if they cannot afford it (where they remain until they can roll doubles in 3 turns, difficult in and of itself, and if they cant, they must pay a fine).
In this era of socially conscious audiences, Hasbro could definitely make a political statement with this new musical. It could star Mr. Monopoly as narrator and speak about the white collar crimes that continue to happen in this country.
Wow, when I decided to write on this I definitely thought I would have a much more cynical view of these adaptations, but it would seem that I am more optimistic than I thought. This all being said, as long as good new works continue to be produced, I will continue to love this wonderful, beautiful art form.